Sunday, March 23, 2008

Obedient, obeisant observance or obsequious obscurantism?...

The longest title on Owsblog and probably all from the same page of the dictionary...and - of course - I'm referring to religion...what better day for that! A constant subject of 'debate' [R5L message board] and one that will never be resolved. As I've mentioned before I'm of the opinion that nearly all religions are/were a way for the well educated and rich to subjugate hoi polloi.

Andrew Clark and Orsolya Lelkes in their paper entitled 'Deliver us from evil: religion as insurance' are basically telling us that believers are happier. Their paper - one of dozens presented at last weeks Royal Economic Society Annual Conference [RES Home] [RES Conference]

...focuses on the insurance role of religion in buffering the well‐being impact of stressful life events, and the ensuing economic and social implications... ...we show that the religious enjoy higher levels of life satisfaction, and that religion does insure against some adverse life events.

Judging by the fact that it seems to concentrate on European data sets - I've only read the abstract - and highlights Catholic and Protestant denominations I'm guessing they refer only to Christianity - hence today's relevance.

Anyway, happy or not they've got some good tunes! (and they say it's the Devil that always has them...he may have: THIS is why.) I wrote here - the 4th comment on this post on Baldinio's blog yesterday - and now I can't stop singing! Oh happy day...

6 comments:

Paul said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Paul said...

Jesus Christ Superstar is the only musical I have any time for. 'I don't know how to love him' sang by Yvonne Eliman is just beautiful - okay it was written by Tim Rice and ALW so nothing is perfect.

My 3x great grandfather wrote hymns, I have a photcopy of the front of his book of melodies published by TC Bates of Ludgate Hill in the 1860's - there's no mention of him on Google so I will have to try the British Library one day. I'll write a post about him at some future point.

In the 1871 census as 'Licensed Victualler and author of the songs of Zion'. I like the juxposition of running a pub (which he did for for nearly 30 years) and writing hymns.

* That was me who binned their post, I'd made an error and it didn't make any sense.

Span Ows said...

Sounds interesting! Strangely enough there were a few holy men in my family line (dad's side - West Country) and yeomen farmers etc. One set up scholarships for local children smart enough for Oxbridge (and here's me dreaming of having enough money!) ;-)

Span Ows said...

P.S. I got both messages...who hymns...hehehehe

P.P.S. I used to like JCSS a lot, and Godspell.

The Great Gildersleeve said...

Whatever the personal opinion of the positive or shortfall of religion and it's part in the history or spiritual well being of any nation, some of the most beautiful music ever written(and today rarely heard)are the hymns and sacred music made for the purpose of praising God.

And I have to admit to being emotionally moved when I hear it.

Perhaps it's time to download some religious music to my pc...

Span Ows said...

Gildy, I agree entirely - incredibly moving stuff much of it.

I'm a particular fan of church organ music - surely the most powerful instrument in existence: Buxtehude and Bach (Johann Sebastian) then later Mendelssohn to name a few of the greats. Echoing round a church during some Christian liturgy is an incredibly moving experience...coincidentally I mentioned in my Easter post (or maybe it was Baldinio's post) re my epiphany etc and I mentioned curch going etc...well I did a bit of liturgical dancing as well! (swoons at the memory) :-)